Fighting Toxic Productivity and Finding Freedom in Compassion
I remember the first time I realized "being busy" didn't necessarily mean "being productive." If you'd seen my to-do list, you would've sworn I was prepping to colonize Mars by the end of the week—nothing short of an interplanetary hustle. But deep down, I was running on fumes. I had a chance to dive deep into this subject with my longtime friend, the unstoppable writer and former pro athlete, Talia Caldwell. In this conversation, we explored real productivity, personal well-being, and how vulnerability can be the glue that holds us all together.
Right out of the gate, Talia obliterated the idea that productivity should revolve around the 9-to-5 industrial model of "live to work." It reminded me of the time I tried to become "ultra-productive" by waking up at 3:00 AM. My body responded with: "Sure, buddy, we'll just hop on the treadmill in your dreams." (I burnt more calories hitting snooze than I ever did jogging.) That experience taught me that pure grit without self-care leads nowhere fast.
Talia's background is equal parts inspiring and humbling. She played NCAA Division I basketball at Cal, became the first women's basketball player admitted to the Haas School of Business (insert hype horn here!), and went on to play professionally around the world. Post-hoops, she shifted her drive and discipline to creative writing and film. She's the kind of person who can outwork basically anyone—but ironically, she's the first to warn against the dangers of pushing yourself to exhaustion with no pause for reflection.
Image of Talia Caldwell taken from ESPN
She talked about how "productivity" itself can become toxic if we're not careful—an all-consuming focus on output that forgets about our basic humanity. Hearing her say that made me think of those motivational posters that scream "WIN 24/7!" Meanwhile, your body is quietly planning a vacation on your behalf because you never offered it one.
One of my favorite points Talia made was that hustle culture should never mean sacrificing your long-term well-being for someone else's ambition. Real talk: as much as we celebrate overtime, not all late nights are created equal. There's a huge difference between working extended hours to chase your own dream and burning the midnight oil just to keep a faceless corporation happy. Talia's own jam-packed schedule was manageable, she said, only because she set a strict timeline and tied her efforts directly to her personal goals—her specific plan to write and get staffed on a TV show, for example.
But Talia's story goes beyond career pursuits. She founded the Echo Park Fund in Los Angeles to help the unhoused and those in transition. If that doesn't make you reevaluate your own giving habits, imagine me raising my hand slowly right now. She's big on the idea that everyone needs a sense of community and a solid support system. She also pointed out that you can change someone's life "just by noticing them." (Sometimes I wonder if the real reason we text so much is so we can ignore people in person.)
Another big theme in our talk was boundaries. "No" is a complete sentence, but it helps to know when, why, and how to use it. Talia acknowledges that she struggles with saying no sometimes, yet she's also quick to guard her energy from anything that doesn't resonate with her. She points out that it's about respecting your own life and your own limits. Setting boundaries might be uncomfortable at first—especially if you're anything like me and have the unstoppable urge to fix everything for everyone—but it's a powerful act of self-preservation.
Something else she touched on was building a tribe of authentic relationships. She loves honest, multilayered people who are open about their successes and their struggles—folks who can admit they're "trying to survive and be better." There's a quirky sense of comfort in that candor. I guess it's a bit like picking your basketball team; you want people who will rebound your missed shots and call you out when you're double dribbling on life.
Ultimately, Talia's message is simple yet profound: let's have compassion for ourselves and for others. If your body is begging for rest, let it rest. If your mind is starving for challenge, feed it with new ideas. Focus on what truly matters—your well-being, your connections with others, and your personal definition of success. Productivity isn't a dirty word, but when it drives you into the ground, it's time to re-evaluate. Because, as Talia reminded me, life is about more than just hitting your mark; it's about staying whole along the way.
If this hit home, you’ll love the Better Dad Bulletin — a free weekly newsletter packed with tools, mindset shifts, and encouragement for modern dads who lead with love and purpose.
Subscribe here: Join Better Dad Bulletin
And if you want to wear your values, explore the Dynamic Daddy Store — gear for growth-minded fathers who live loud and love harder.
Shop here: Dynamic Daddy Store